Literally. lol
If we're assuming that this is the current me who has read Animorphs, then I'd probably get caught pretty darned quickly. If I heard of a social club called The Sharing, for example, I'd probably assume it was formed by an Animorphs fan, and want to find out if I'm right. So, yeah. I'd probably get caught.
If this was an alternate universe me who'd never read Animorphs, then I'd probably find something about it on the internet, laugh and think people are freaking out over nothing like with 2012 and H1N1, comment about it outloud, and... well... Get caught.
Man, I'd be screwed either way. ^^;