2. the andalite's gift (loved how they repeated scenes from different characters
This is something K.A stopped doing in the rest of the Megamorphs because apparently a lot of people hated it. I loved it though. it was interesting to see the same scenario play out from a different perspective.
Oh well.
For me, it'd be:
#1 - I really loved how this one played out like a movie. It just seemed epic.
#3 - I love the fact that we got some continuation from Elfangor's consequences from Andalite Chronicles in here.
#2 - Meh. The whole dinosaur thing seemed like a gimmick to me. Almost like a fan fiction story, but I didn't hate it.
#4 - A "What if..." story? Really? Not very original. Plus, the TV show came out with the story for this before the books did, which only further proves the point. The only redeeming value of this was that we got a bit more development on Ellimist's and Crayak's game, and how the Ellimist stacked his odds.