Richard's Animorphs Forum
Animorphs Section => Animorphs Forum Classic => Topic started by: CounterInstinct on September 29, 2010, 11:32:58 PM
-
A lot of people say they hate the Helmacrons because they're a lot more annoying than roaches.
I think they've done their role. They're supposed to be annoying, and they achieved their goal. The Animorphs were annoyed to wits' end by the Helmacrons, as well as us, the readers. And the Helmacrons haven't shrunk us yet. YET.
So I think, if there would be a rewrite, despite fan protests, the Helmacrons should stay. :) C'mon, they're funny. Admit it. :P
-
Nope.
;)
-
Yeah I'm pretty sure they're supposed to be annoying. There's a difference between having an annoying character that you're supposed to be annoyed with, and having an annoying character that the creator expects you to take seriously or sympathize with.
-
No, you're supposed to be annoyed with the Helmacrons. SO, for that reason they should stay. However, the Helmacron books SUCKED, least favourite of all the ones I read, I really think those should be rewritten. The species themselves could stay, I actually liked the guys, just annoying, it was the writing style, and storyline, that annoying the ever loving PISS out of me. :P
-
Yeah, they succeed in their purpose, which is to annoy people, but the question then becomes "why on Earth did KA and Grant have 'annoying people' as their goal?".
And both of their books were just pathetically bad. #24 has some good humor, but paragraph upon paragraph is devoted to "stuff's big!" as if the Anis have never morphed anything small before, and #42 is just embarrassing.
-
The Helmacrons were possibly the most annoying people...er, aliens I've heard of. And how one of them gets called Wuss....that is so unreal...
-
I consciously love the helmacrons and allows admitted it so :P
-
"Who dares speak such treacherous thoughts against the all-invincible Helmacron dynasty!!! Cower in terror!!!"[/size
NOTE: this is not a RP comment.
I like the Helmacrons... those little egotistical fleas. They just cause so much mayhem; I find them funny, and yeah, annoying as heck.
-
yeah i like em'. :)
-
"Who dares speak such treacherous thoughts against the all-invincible Helmacron dynasty!!! Cower in terror!!!"[/size
NOTE: this is not a RP comment.
I like the Helmacrons... those little egotistical fleas. They just cause so much mayhem; I find them funny, and yeah, annoying as heck.
They're funny and annoying...which is why that sort of reminds me of Marco. I once dreamed Marco got trapped in a mutant form of Helmacron/himself.
-
Naw, my twenty-two year old self still insists these are adult books written for kids and the Helmacrons totally don't fit into that mould :p
-
I think, to be frank, that all the alien species in Animorphs had too clear of a purpose initially. The Andalites were the "good guys," the Yeerks "the bad guys," and the Hork-Bajir were the "seriously badass minions." Now granted the world of the books eventually expand until this isn't true anymore. Like at all. And there were multiple other whacked species by this point, like the Skrit Na. And it already had started by #24, but not as far as it went. But still.
So if I were a writer creating a book series for kids, I almost would want to create a species that totally screwed that up. A species that was just plain annoying. x3 So yeah, it was total filler. And #42 was written so badly that I just left the series at that point. XD
But you've gotta love the little bastards. ;)
-
I agree with Red that this series should have been directed towards older teenagers or young adults, but for some reason were directed towards preteens. Though I was 15 when they started coming out, so I was at just the right age.
-
I was 17 when I started reading them. >.< Always been embarrassed of that. Lol. IDK, I thought the Helmacrons were a good filler, in theory, I've always thought it'd be cool if there were a planet, life supporting, out there that was TINY, and had TINY little people on it, so that was cool enough, but... Ugh. The books they were in! Honestly, those are my two least favourite of the entire series!
-
I agree with Red that this series should have been directed towards older teenagers or young adults, but for some reason were directed towards preteens. Though I was 15 when they started coming out, so I was at just the right age.
Yeah... I mean, from what I can gather the pre-teens that read them weren't total morons but for a series that dealt with massively important and challenging things, the Helmacrons were a little patronising.
-
I kinda think that the Helmacrons add some variety in the series. I know there a lot of other aliens to keep track of too, but that alone doesn't make the Helmacrons unneccessary or worthless Come to think of it, none of the other aliens that weren't introduced in the first book ever had a major, story-changing effect on the series, not even the Howlers. (Okay the Elimist and Crayak did, and I guess the Chee, but still...) If there is life out there, I expect there to be a lot of it, so they didn't bother me too much as far as being in the series goes. They did bother me though, in their own unique ways.
-
I kinda think that the Helmacrons add some variety in the series. I know there a lot of other aliens to keep track of too, but that alone doesn't make the Helmacrons unneccessary or worthless Come to think of it, none of the other aliens that weren't introduced in the first book ever had a major, story-changing effect on the series, not even the Howlers. (Okay the Elimist and Crayak did, and I guess the Chee, but still...) If there is life out there, I expect there to be a lot of it, so they didn't bother me too much as far as being in the series goes. They did bother me though, in their own unique ways.
O.o I agree with...all of what you said.
-
And besides, they're really fun to RP! I'm glad they're in there!
-
I loved the first Helmacron book. Hated the second one. So I guess.... Good concept, bad execution?
-
Personally, I liked the Helmacrons. Their "we're going to conquer the galaxy and each other, all at the same time" attitude was rather amusing, especially given their tiny size. The fact that they actually managed to be a real threat to the Anis on occasion was a neat aspect of the series, too.
Yeah, the Helmacron books were mostly filler, but IMHO it was good filler. I also think it was nice to get a break from the really serious missions (that goes for #24 in particular, when the Animorphs had just finished with David).