Richard's Animorphs Forum

Animorphs Section => Animorphs Forum Classic => Topic started by: urbanblade829 on July 30, 2008, 04:36:13 PM

Title: Morphing Problems
Post by: urbanblade829 on July 30, 2008, 04:36:13 PM
We all know that if you morph something smaller the excess mass is extruded into Z-Space. 

But where does the extra mass come from if you morph something larger?

Mass simply coming into existence breaks the laws of conservation of matter.  The only way that that could happen is if a large amount of matter was created by energy, but the energy required to do that is enormous.  So where does the extra mass come from?
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: wolfev on July 30, 2008, 04:43:58 PM
I think there is exist mass in Z space as well. Ax mentions it in 12 The Reaction that Rachel has to make a whole crocodile with the excess mass in Z space.
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: morfowt on July 30, 2008, 05:22:14 PM
I don't know. Ax also says in #18 that there is absolutely nothing in Zero-space, not even a few molecules (or particles? I don't remember the term) like in normal space.
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Tyler on July 30, 2008, 05:28:49 PM
More morphing problems? Come ON K.A.!!!!!!
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: wotw2112 on July 30, 2008, 05:50:19 PM
Hmm...good point.

Maybe they borrow it from others in morph elsewhere in the universe?  Does time exist in Z-Space?  If not it could be any number of things that wouldn't necessarily be intuitive to humans.

Or of course it could be the old standby explanation:

MAGIC!  ;D
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: wolfev on July 30, 2008, 06:03:16 PM
Maybe its where all that andalite waste goes. They do have one hell of a bathroom.
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: wotw2112 on July 30, 2008, 07:53:55 PM
Maybe its where all that andalite waste goes. They do have one hell of a bathroom.

Ha!  Maybe so.  It bears...less consideration.  :-X
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Liz on July 30, 2008, 11:10:40 PM
I always wondered where the extra mass came from too...

Maybe there's some kind of "mass repository" in a little corner of Z-space, created by Andalite scientists for use when morphing. xD 
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Phoenix004 on July 31, 2008, 09:36:39 AM
Since the Andalites are estimated to be at least a century or two ahead of us and KA doesn't have a degree in advanced Physics, we don't really know enough about Zero Space to be able to guess how the morphing technology works. Zero Space is said to be the opposite of normal space, like matter and anti-matter. Regular space consists of a vacuum, which is complete nothingness. Perhaps Zero Space is the opposite, in the sense that there is nothing solid there, but instead consists of 'potential' mass. This potential mass could then be used to create the extra mass needed in larger morphs.

And before you ask, I have NO idea what I'm talking about, but it seemed to make more sense in my head!  :P
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Starsword on July 31, 2008, 09:55:14 AM
Sidenote: Tyler, nice MST3K  Cave Dwellers reference. Fantastic movie
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Dameg on July 31, 2008, 10:35:52 AM
I also thought about that... I think this is a KASU ^_^'
But if we really wanna explain that... may be the extra mass Rachel use when she morphs an elephant come from an Andalite who is morphing a chadoo or something like that ^_^' ... not a very good explanation ^_^'
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Starsword on July 31, 2008, 10:39:23 AM
Since the Andalites are estimated to be at least a century or two ahead of us and KA doesn't have a degree in advanced Physics, we don't really know enough about Zero Space to be able to guess how the morphing technology works.
I agree, heck, scientists are exploring dark matter, something they thought was just nothingness. Ax is always laughing at human science, so it seems plausible that its just too advanced for our understanding.
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Kelran-Isthinar on July 31, 2008, 10:35:04 PM
My Assumption is this;

Matter and Energy can not be created or destroyed, but they can be transmuted, something the Andalite Race seems fond of doing to everything.

So if Z-Space acts as I think it does, it can serve as a massive raw energy siphon.
And the morphing technology just might convert the energy into mass when needed, bleeding it back into Z-Space when its no logner needed.

Think of it as a combo of the Star Trek Replicator and the Stargate ZPM.
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Phoenix004 on August 01, 2008, 09:16:13 AM
My Assumption is this;

Matter and Energy can not be created or destroyed, but they can be transmuted, something the Andalite Race seems fond of doing to everything.

So if Z-Space acts as I think it does, it can serve as a massive raw energy siphon.
And the morphing technology just might convert the energy into mass when needed, bleeding it back into Z-Space when its no logner needed.

Think of it as a combo of the Star Trek Replicator and the Stargate ZPM.

Is it weird that I understood that? And that I know what Tempus Fugit means?  :P
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: morfowt on August 01, 2008, 09:17:52 AM
weird you understood? no. heck, I understood.
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Kelran-Isthinar on August 01, 2008, 09:40:27 AM
No its not wierd at all  :)

Well correction, define wierd, I know by alot of peoples' standards this entire conversation would classify as 'wierd'
so wierd is relative.
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: morfowt on August 01, 2008, 09:44:49 AM
well normally, this whole forum would be weird, but in RAF terms of weird, like say not knowing what battle morph jake uses most, would be weird.
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Kelran-Isthinar on August 01, 2008, 11:10:36 AM
Precisely!  ;D
So weird, like distance, time, color, shape, movement, and position, has been relegated to eternal relative-ness.
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Phoenix004 on August 01, 2008, 01:39:39 PM
I have no problem with weirdness. I like weird people, they are far more fun to be around than "normal" people.

Anyway, back to the topic. Maybe it would have been easier if KA hadn't mentioned the idea of storing excess mass in Zero Space? Then we wouldn't have had this problem. Of course, then she couldn't have done book 18...
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: jtuttle on August 01, 2008, 01:41:03 PM
I have no problem with weirdness. I like weird people, they are far more fun to be around than "normal" people.

Witness the existence of this forum, for example :-)

-- J.P.
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: goom on October 23, 2008, 03:53:09 PM
maybe you 'borrow' mass from other morphers (that have extra mass in z space)
that'd be a little awkward :D
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Liz on October 23, 2008, 03:59:00 PM
I thought that would be logical, but what would happen if there wasn't enough mass at the time to complete your morph? xD  I picture one of those internet error messages saying "The mass server is too busy, please try again later."

I wonder how many Andalites are in the military?  They are the ones who would be using the morphing technology, and I think it said somewhere that it's only used by spies and the like.  So maybe there wouldn't be enough individuals morphing at one time to provide enough mass for others' use.
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: goom on October 23, 2008, 04:34:43 PM
i kind of imagine it like a torrent, if anybody knows how that works.

that would explain why the morphing process is so different/random all the time.
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: zaprowsdower on October 23, 2008, 10:56:25 PM
So what's a torrent?
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: morfowt on October 24, 2008, 05:37:19 AM
I know how to use torrents, but I have no idea what they are or how they're made...
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Gafrash on October 24, 2008, 08:10:38 PM
Neither....

Hey! I always assumed that upon copying the DNA of an animal into yourself, you are LITERALLY COPYING EVERYTHING about that animal that is stored within its DNA. Like how it looks at the equivalent age (characteristics), how tall and heavy it is (mass), its senses and capabilities, its instincts (mind) and all.
So its physical AND the mental 'copy' would literally be made, 'copied' into an exact replica and 'stored' in Z-Space.
And the morphing energy is the power that changes each cell on the morpher's body into that of the animal it is going to be come.
All very abstract, I know.
But the morpher is able to focus on the animal to initiate change and thus the morphing begins. The transfer of the excess mass would be from the 'made' copy and not 'borrowed' from some other source. So I would imagine, if I was to morph a bug, ALL MY ATOMS would MORPH into that of said bug, and as my mind stays in 3-D space along with the bug body and the bug's mind, my physical form would be literally floating comatose in Z-Space nowheres, until my mind in the 3-D plane would call upon it and demorph back.


I'd like to add the topic here, that I never quite got the mechanics of the Escafil device. Supposedly a morph-capable person with knowledge of the tech can transfer the tech. But then came the ant which happened to touch the blue cube and then touched Cassie, it being a non-sentient creature with barely any self-awareness in the series, MANAGED to acquire Cassie and morph into a human.
How the heck did that happen????????!

And in book #1 (I know, I know there are a lot of K.A.S.U.s based on Michael and Katherine still establishing 'the ropes' of the whole Animorphs philosophy) Jake as Homer, smells all sorts of things and identifies dogs from down the road... the authors were trying to play with the concept of memory and didn't quite follow it up, like they were undecided after that.
But by the time Cassie morphed Rachel in  #12: The Reaction she implies something similar again. How Cassie says Rachel's brain just wants to do stupid things...
We know that instincts are stored in DNA, but could the morphing process in the series suggest that things like 'memory' and 'personality of sentient species' are also stored in DNA?! If not, this is certainly implied through the Arns' ixcilla.

So I imagine under this technology of morphing comes the components of DNA, cell transformation, inter-dimensional transference (whoa!), healing (bc the process doesn't hurt nor retain injuries), telepathy and some extra component that enables the morpher to bring in clothing, and their water and food and stuff like the Yeerk pest inside their head with them.
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Gafrash on October 24, 2008, 08:37:34 PM
Maaaaaan, the more I think about it, the more I find issues with this technology.
THERE ARE LOTS OF UNEXPLAINED THINGS... Kinda wish Ax would have let us in a few more during his narrations.
Like, how the age factor is ignored. If they acquired, say, an old bird, would they morph the animal at that exact age, or at their respective teenage-hoods?!
How Marco morphed a fat man, implying that 'fat' is stored in DNA.

The issue with the clothing business is another big one. It indicates that something more than DNA is at work in the morphing business. The Animorphs only managed to do skin tight stuff, but I remember Estrid blew my mind when she managed to do full-blown clothing in The Arrival. What's with that?!

Also, (can't remember in which book) but they were once hungry and upon feeding in wolf morph, and demorphing into human, they ceased to be hungry. This suggests that even biological functions are transferred with the excess mass and all...

I am blowing my brains thinking about all this, here. NGHAAAAAAAAAARRRRRR RRRGH!!!!
Better not go down this path, guys, and just go with it.

It exists in the Animorphs Universe, therefore it is!
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: estrid on October 26, 2008, 03:38:56 PM
the way i always looked at this was that they acquired the DNA  from the animals rite? and that DNA pattern was being used so they could morph into that animal. well the DNA would start forming whatever needed forming, and even if the animal was bigger, it wouldn't take the excess mass from anywhere. It would just build it. think of how when a tadpole turns into a frog. its getting bigger, things are disappearing. nothing is goin in2 z-space.  or look at a developing embryo, like when  u have the developing baby getting bigger, its all the genetix coming into play.
its just the DNA codes causing the formation of the new organs and causing the frog to grow. same with morphing something large. the DNA for the trunk of the elephant 4 example would start the forming of the trunk.
damn it id make a horrible bio teacher. i know all this stuff and it all makes sense in my head, i just suck at explaining it
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: morfowt on October 26, 2008, 05:31:26 PM
yeah, but ax mentioned at least twice that when morphing something smaller, the excess mass goes into z-space...
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: estrid on October 26, 2008, 06:12:33 PM
ya i kno, but im talking bout getting bigger
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: morfowt on October 27, 2008, 04:43:56 AM
so to demorph the extra mass goes into z-space? would z-space have to much extra mass in it one day?
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: zaprowsdower on October 27, 2008, 04:10:05 PM
Z-space is infinite, if I'm not mistaken.
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Tim Bruening on July 10, 2015, 12:02:12 AM
Quote
Maaaaaan, the more I think about it, the more I find issues with this technology.
THERE ARE LOTS OF UNEXPLAINED THINGS... Kinda wish Ax would have let us in a few more during his narrations.
Like, how the age factor is ignored. If they acquired, say, an old bird, would they morph the animal at that exact age, or at their respective teenage-hoods?!
How Marco morphed a fat man, implying that 'fat' is stored in DNA.

The issue with the clothing business is another big one. It indicates that something more than DNA is at work in the morphing business. The Animorphs only managed to do skin tight stuff, but I remember Estrid blew my mind when she managed to do full-blown clothing in The Arrival. What's with that?!

Also, (can't remember in which book) but they were once hungry and upon feeding in wolf morph, and demorphing into human, they ceased to be hungry. This suggests that even biological functions are transferred with the excess mass and all...

Book 25 "The Extreme".  however, in another book, Tobias has to eat part of a hamburger in his hawk form, which implies that if he ate it all in human form, it wouldn't nourish his hawk form.
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Dylan on July 11, 2015, 06:03:28 PM
Thinking about it, the whole anteater ending in 24 makes no since. How exactly would morphing anteater fix their size?
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Tim Bruening on July 11, 2015, 09:17:19 PM
Thinking about it, the whole anteater ending in 24 makes no since. How exactly would morphing anteater fix their size?

The Animorphs and all their morph DNA had been shrunk by the Helmacron shrinking ray.  The Anteater DNA was of normal size, so that when the Animorphs used it, they became full sized anteaters!  So did Visser 3.

What would have happened had the unshrink ray been used on the full sized anteaters?
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Dylan on July 11, 2015, 09:29:26 PM
Uhhh okay. Still doesn't make much since.
Title: Re: Morphing Problems
Post by: Tim Bruening on July 12, 2015, 08:20:12 PM
What would happen if the unshrinking ray were used on an organism that is already at full size?