Richard's Animorphs Forum

Animorphs Section => Animorphs Forum Classic => Topic started by: Dogman15 on September 17, 2016, 04:55:45 AM

Title: Importance of each book in the overall storyline
Post by: Dogman15 on September 17, 2016, 04:55:45 AM

I was thinking again today about a hypothetical Animorphs TV series for the modern age. Some books are very important and would undeniably have to be turned into episodes. But some books could be skipped, glossed over, or the events thereof mentioned or alluded to in a different episode. So I dedided to look at all 64 books and judge how important they would be to an overall series of theatrical or DTV films and episodes of a TV series.

A 0 means "This book is trash and should be completely forgotten about, it would never need to see an adaptation", and 100 means "This book is absolutely essential to understanding the full story of the Animorphs and the Yeerk-Andalite war at large." Anything inbetween could potentially mean "this book would be cool to see on screen, but it's not that important to understanding the whole story".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Animorphs_books (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Animorphs_books)
http://animorphs.wikia.com/wiki/List_of_Animorphs_books (http://animorphs.wikia.com/wiki/List_of_Animorphs_books)
MM1 = 40
MM2 = 25
MM3 = 30
MM4 = 33
The Andalite Chronicles = 95
The Hork-Bajir Chronicles = 90
Visser = 92
The Ellimist Chronicles = 20
Alternamorphs 1: The First Journey = 5
Alternamorphs 2: The Next Passage = 2
Book 1 (The Invasion) (just the numbers from now on) = 100
2 = 90
3 = 88
4 = 100
5 = 80
6 = 75
7 = 80
8 = 80
9 = 70
10 = 85
11 = 52
12 = 55
13 = 95
14 = 65
15 = 95
16 = 80
17 = 70
18 = 74
19 = 87
20 = 95
21 = 95
22 = 95
23 = 93
24 = 65
25 = 67
26 = 82
27 = 70
28 = 50
29 = 75
30 = 88
31 = 70
32 = 75
33 = 66
34 = 71
35 = 80
36 = 47
37 = 55
38 = 70
39 = 35
40 = 40 Oh hey, they match.
41 = 30
42 = 30
43 = 50
44 = 55
45 = 100
46 = 75
47 = 79
48 = 34
49 = 90
50 = 88
51 = 90
52 = 100
53 = 100
54 = 100

Would you assign a different value of importance to any book? How's my assessment?

Title: Re: Importance of each book in the overall storyline
Post by: RYTX on September 17, 2016, 07:56:11 AM

So 0-100 is to wide a range for me.  I'll do 0-10, 10 being vital, 0 being discardable (amazed you didn't give anything a zero!), and explain why for some.

1-10
2-1 some insight into Rachel, but her portrayal changes so much after this it's negilable. The stuff about Chapman's sacrifice for his kid never really is of consequence again
3-4 Interesting to see Tobias come to terms with himself (for a while) but not vital
4-10
5-9 Macro's motives and set up for a lot of his books
6-7
7-7 Like the Ellimist intro, but really this is because it's the first time they do hard damage
8-6 book itself is of little consequence, till it sets up 45
9- 0
10-8
11-0
12-0
13-8
14-0
15-8
16-0
17-0
18-4 so much promise. Shame
19-9
20-8 Great book, but the David-Narrator effects is the least of the trilogy
21-10
22-10
23-2
24-0 still love this one, but it is a joke book
25-1
26-4
27-3
28-0 and they admit it
29-5
30-7
31-1
32-1
33-3 only because it has a follow up
34-0
35-1 ONLY for the last paragraph
36-1
37-1
38-3 again potential, but not achieved
39-0
40-0 Ax hates cripples, and Marco doesn't. Okay. Doesn't change things much
41-0
42-0
43-3
44-0
45-10
46-8
47-1
48-6
49-10
50-10
51-6
52-9
53-10
54-10
TAC-2
HBC-2
TEC-1
Visser-0
MM1-1
MM2-1
MM3-1
MM4-1
Alt1- -12
Alt2- -12

Title: Re: Importance of each book in the overall storyline
Post by: Dogman15 on September 18, 2016, 12:52:42 PM

Interesting numbers.

If anyone else is reading this thread and would like some images of each book, they can be seen in archive here: http://web.archive.org/web/20050523000835/http://www.scholastic.com/animorphs/books/animorphography/ (http://web.archive.org/web/20050523000835/http://www.scholastic.com/animorphs/books/animorphography/)

Title: Re: Importance of each book in the overall storyline
Post by: YeerkSalad on October 06, 2016, 09:27:18 PM

Why are the Alternamorphs in the negatives?

Title: Re: Importance of each book in the overall storyline
Post by: Quaf on October 07, 2016, 05:13:50 AM

Because there's nothing positive about them

Title: Re: Importance of each book in the overall storyline
Post by: YeerkSalad on October 07, 2016, 04:30:22 PM

you just SHREKT those books

Title: Re: Importance of each book in the overall storyline
Post by: Dylan on October 09, 2016, 07:10:18 PM

Cuz I'm bored
1-10
2-6
3-6
4-10
5-10
6-5
7-10
MM1-5
8-8
9-5
10-10
11-4
12-5
TAC-10
13-10
14-4
15-8
16-6
17-4
MM2-3
18-8
19-10
20-10
21-10
22-10
THBC-10
23-9
24-6
25-4
26-8
ATM1-0
27-7
28-2
29-9
MM3-6
30-10
31-4
32-6
33-10
34-5
35-6 (the ending leads into Visser)
V-10
36-1
37-5
38-8
39-1
40-2
ATM2-1
MM4-7
41-1
42-1
43-5
44-4
45-10
46-7
47-6
TEC-7
48-7
49-10
50-10
51-10
52-10
53-10
54-10